Review: Aviary

Redolent of the sea, oysters at Aviary come five to a plate on a sparkling bed of ice. They hit the tongue like silk, sliding back, the tiny summer tang of tomato granite, building to the barest hint of horseradish, and then as they go down, a whisper of salty ocean air, like you are standing on a beach in a warm breeze.

When you start a meal at Aviary with oysters, their perfect flavor balance will set the tone, but you still will not be prepared for the dishes to come. Oxtail croquettes stand in formation like sushi. Whatever urge you may have, don’t break them – they are meant to be eaten whole. Pop one into your mouth and bite down. First the crunchy smooth breading and then jets of deep earthy flavors envelop the palate. Rich acid and the sweetness of tomato jam pull everything together.

Milk-Braised Veal Breast – carrots & celery, ginger mustard

Follow them with two small pieces of velvety milk-braised veal breast. They are so tender and soft you’ll want to eat them by themselves, but the dishes here are all from a palette, meant to be combined, so place them between two tiny lightly sweetened buns, and add some pickled carrots, cilantro, mint and cucumbers until you have a tiny Banh Mi-like sandwich. Each vanishes in a couple of bites with a burst of flavor that leaves you craving more. Another night the veal was replaced with luscious, tender goose, the slightly gamey flavors contrasting wildly with the brightness of the other ingredients with an explosion of flavors, smells and textures.

This is the way most of the dishes work at Aviary, one of the newest and best restaurants in Portland. The food they serve is executed with a rare degree of excellence. It is not merely to be consumed; it’s meant to be thought about, tasted with eyes closed, lingered over, and discussed with a good friend. I worry whether there are enough people here willing to pause a conversation for a moment and think about what the chef was trying to achieve when he created the plate. The food is sophisticated, and from the buzz around town, it seems this is not the restaurant to go to with friends who don’t have a good palate. Go with people who are adventurous and interested in food. Like any restaurant, people either get it, or they don’t; nothing wrong with that.

Aviary Chefs Counter

Aviary Chefs Counter. photo: Star Chefs

Housed in an inconspicuous space on NE Alberta next to Barista Coffeehouse, Aviary doesn’t seem like something different or special from the street. It is sparse and modern, with an abundance of concrete, white walls and an open, medium-sized room. The seating is mostly two and four tops, with a small chef’s counter across the kitchen. A single sprig of rosemary decorates each table (simple, but annoying when they get tall).

Aviary was opened by three chefs, Sara Pliner, Jasper Shen and Kat Whithead, who between them have a portfolio that’s a who’s who of New York restaurants – Jean Georges, Aldea, Ducasse, Aquavit, 5 Ninth…  the list goes on. One night I sat at the counter and watched them working. I didn’t see a sous, just three chefs on equal footing, each cooking in their own world. I think this gives them more room to experiment without having to keep an eye on what everyone else in the kitchen is doing.

Octopus Salad

With all the different textures, flavors and contrasts in Aviary’s dishes, the chefs have to be on their toes to make them work. The food is based on French technique, with Asian fusion elements. This is modern dining, and the perfect way to do fusion; each cuisine enhances the other without getting in the way. Dishes show juxtaposition between the way Aviary can move between simplicity, and complexity bordering on molecular gastronomy without resorting to gimmickry.

I am sure that comments will be made about the prices. Though they may seem high on first glance, for the quality of the food being served, they are quite reasonable. It is always a surprise to order a $10 dish and get six Tater-Tot sized rolls on a plate, but I always waddle out the door for around $80 for two persons, including desserts. I wouldn’t want to spend that much every day, but I think the food here it is well worth it. As a friend of mine from Los Angeles said, “You wouldn’t believe what this meal would cost me at home!” For two people, I usually order six or seven dishes.

The house cocktail list is a small but interesting mix of palate cleansing starters which will be perfect as warmer weather arrives. Some of my favorites are the rhubarb cooler with vodka, basil and rhubarb, the quarter horse which features bourbon, Thai basil and fresh blood orange with a slightly sweet, peppery rim, or the Aviary Flower which includes gin, St. Germain and Grapefruit juice.

The beer list is short but intriguing – Trumer pils, Boneyard rpm ipa, Boneyard diabo rojo, Great Divide hoss rye, Old German lager, Hitachino Nest white ale, and 21st Amendment bitter American.  The same could be said for the wine list – some really interesting choices are available, most in the $30-$40 dollar range. About 11 are available by the glass. Markup on some of the more unusual bottles is lower than I would expect.

All meals start with a humble bagna càuda dipping sauce. It is a warm, creamy Piedmontese sauce of butter, anchovies, olive oil and garlic, and is brought to your table as soon as you are seated, along with slices of crusty Pearl Bakery baguette and olive bread.

Salads are unusual, always showcasing the ingredients in new and interesting ways. One combines lightly dressed arugula, strips of Asian pear and celery root, thin bright wheels of watermelon radish and tiny grains of candied cumin. Without the latter, the near perfect composition of the other ingredients would make it stand out, but the scattering of the spicy little grains are like a spark waking the mind.

Aviary warm snap pea and barley salad

Warm Snap Pea and Barley Salad. photo: Star Chefs

A salad of warm snap peas and barley is a gastronomic puzzle, a clever brain tease on how to eat the dish. A large crunchy barley disk astride a brilliant salad hides the surprises beneath. Tender snap peas and un-hulled cooked barley line the plate with distinctive delicate hon shimejis Asian mushrooms and lily bulbs. Marble-sized spheres, one containing orange juice and rose-water, the other yogurt, act as little yolks of flavor. Pop them with a fork to change the texture and tastes, mixing as you go or just in bites. Switch to another dish and come back a few minutes later, and you’ll find the flavors have bloomed. I was transported to a rose garden.

Soups are always the mark of a kitchen’s skills and imagination. Aviary nails it in a marvelous cauliflower velouté, so creamy it borders on foam. It envelops thinly sliced chestnuts which add a surprising sweetness and texture, along with captivating cinnamon-y shiso, and the salty pop of American Caviar.

Dungeness strudel come two to a plate. Thin flaky pastry enrobes fresh crab, allowing it to cook yet keeping it crispy and creamy, again tasting of the sea. While satisfying and perfectly prepared, I felt it was missing something, lacking the wow factor present in many other dishes, and on one evening the crab was a bit watery.

Aviary Portland - Brioche-crusted halibut

Brioche-Crusted Halibut. photo: Star Chefs

The brioche-crusted halibut stands out from anything similar in town. Three light brown and white stuffed spheres of halibut, with just enough fat to taste sushi-like, stand alluringly in a vibrant green pool of butter-poached cucumber and dark green shiso. Each is topped with a tiny orange bump of sea urchin and a dot of paste made from umeboshi fruit as an accent. Smooth yet pungent greens with wasabi, toasty sesame oil and a hailstorm of sesame seeds sit to the side. If you take a bite from the edge of the halibut it tastes like fish sticks, but swirl one in the sauce and pop it whole into your mouth and a parade of flavors will be revealed, a synergy of rich fish, soft popping sea urchin, cooling cucumber and the complex umami of umeboshi and shiso.

A plate of seared octopus salad looks like a kitchen mistake – black charred octopus appearing as tough as a tire but magically tender. Squares of crusty fried chickpeas mingle with yogurt, pimento and whole Kabuli chickpeas. Mix it all together, and even if you’ve never liked octopus, you’ll find the intriguing flavors pulling you back to the plate. This salad is a masterpiece, showcasing not only technique but the art of construct and balance.

Crispy Pig Ears

Order the tempura pumpkin during a break from other dishes, as its strong flavor tends to overwhelm. The lightly fried pumpkin hints of lemon grass and kaffir lime. They are perched in a shimmering red coconut curry sauce with a complexity that lays waste to most of its ilk. Though on occasion the tempura is a bit too soft, the dish is outstanding, an unexpected spicy departure from other items on the menu.

New York strip steak sounds pedestrian, and when it arrives looks pretty average fanned across the plate. My first bite left me unimpressed, but when I dipped it into the Serrano ham marmalade and scooped it up with a bit of braised endive and a grape, I was transported, reminding me once more that the components in these dishes are meant to be consumed as one. It’s not the best dish on the menu, but it is satisfying, and a larger serving than most of the other choices.

I hadn’t had crispy pig ears in a long time and was excited to see them on the menu. They are, in a word, perfect. When the paella pan is brought to the table you are assaulted with the hot scent of steaming coconut rice, which acts as an aromatic basket for salty chunks of Chinese sausage, avocado and barely wilted greens. Black vinegar-pickled daikon are scattered throughout, providing little prickly strands of flavor. The ears are delicate crispy wafers, almost like a meaty potato chip, the rice so rich I could eat an entire bowl. Every time I ordered this dish other people at the table recoiled, but it always ended up being the star of the night.

Another excellent choice is the “spiced duck leg and broth, slow poached egg, daikon and dates, brioche persillade”. Served in a small bowl, it’s an wonderfully complex, earthy broth, the egg a creamy foil to the dates and duck.

Aviary Portland - Pork Ribs

Pork Ribs – tamarind glaze, papaya slaw

A few plates aren’t particularly interesting. Shao Xing chicken with asparagus tapenade, leeks and bright gogi berries needs a little tweaking, but still gets props for being perfectly prepared – juicy and tender. The asparagus tapenade is interesting, and though wolfberries are a classic combination with chicken and look pretty on the plate, they did little to enhance the flavor. This is more like a dish you might find at any number of Portland restaurants, albeit with more sophisticated ingredients.

I found the pork ribs to be somewhat disappointing, and I wondered if they are only on the menu for those who are less adventurous. They are fairly large, and the meat literally falls off the bones as you move them around your plate. A sprinkling of brilliantly colored Madagascar pepper provides a punch of contrast, but I found the tamarind glaze uninspired, especially after the other dishes. However, a small daikon radish slaw on the side was an outstanding foil to the meat, the vinegar cutting the fat and reopening the palate.

Another dish that didn’t thrill me was the slow poached egg with yuzu cream, morels and radishes. The egg itself is terrific – cooked sous vide, it is wonderfully creamy. The yuzu, a tart Asian citrus, combines well with the egg and woodsy morels, but to me, the way the foam hovers over the top provides a texture that is off-putting. I ordered it several times because I really like the blend of flavors, but never could get beyond thinking how good it could be if it was just a little differently structured. On the other hand, another PFD eater almost hung up on me as we argued back and forth, she solidly in favor of the foam.

Aviary Portland - Pana Cotta

Pana Cotta. photo: Star Chefs

The desserts are not only very fairly priced at $6, but works of art, and some of the best in the city. Try the outstanding pana cotta, which rises far above most. Passion fruit sorbet, mango gelee and little fennel filo crisps compose the dish. The passion fruit sorbet gives a tremendous blast of flavor, the pana cotta a lovely creamy, sour foil. It’s a terrific refreshing palate cleanser and complete harmony of flavors.

My personal favorite is the coconut bread pudding. It is unbelievably light yet creamy and moist. All bread should be so lucky as to end up in a dish this good. A crispy caramel wafer is perched on top, all floating over a pond of unbelievably nutty sesame caramel, and a small mound of citrus with ginger provides even further contrast for a lovely amalgam of flavors.

I’ve only tried the rhubarb mascarpone tart once, but it is another example of how much of a difference a little creativity makes. The tart itself would be fine, but when given a really good “fortune cookie” crust it stands far above the pack.

Beer Ice Cream

Beer Ice Cream. photo: Star Chefs

The beer ice cream is so different from expectations, you will find yourself passing it across the table to share with your companions. Beer is reduced by freezing. Then, by reserving the concentrate which melts first, the ice is discarded. This reduction is mixed into a vanilla ice cream base for an unexpectedly creamy and mellow beer taste.  The final plating is surrounded by a dark pool of coffee which has been set with a little gelatin. Salty crumbles of pretzel sprinkled across the top provide a bit of crunch. It is a marvelous execution of an unusual dish.

Aviary bows to those who must have chocolate for dessert with chocolate cake, spiced pears, port sorbet and a crispy cinnamon stick. I wasn’t particularly interested in this dish, as I’ve had enough boring chocolate desserts to last a lifetime, but as with so many things on the menu, I was quite surprised. The cake was not too sweet and was lighter than I expected, but still moist, holding its shape like an intense chocolate pillow. Thin slices of carefully caramelized pears were perched atop. When the intensity of the chocolate threatened to overwhelm, a quick dip into the complex sweet port sorbet smoothed everything out.

Steven Smith Teas, and French press coffee are an enjoyable way to finish your meal, though the French press is plastic, which is rather incongruous to everything else brought to the table.

On most nights, the service is very good. The staff is happy to offer suggestions and guide you through the various menu options. However, on busy nights, they seem to get overwhelmed, and dishes tend to get plopped on to the table without any sort of explanation about what is what, and any special instructions on the best way to approach them.

The menu can be confusing, and needs to be organized a bit better. Some of the dishes on the menu under “larger plates” don’t belong there, which is a bit annoying when planning your meal. I’d love to see them do a tasting menu for entire tables. While the restrooms are wheelchair accessible, they keys hang on a hook by the door, and are very difficult to reach from a wheelchair.

Those of you who have followed my reviews will be aware that I tend to like simple dishes where the ingredients are allowed to speak for themselves.  To me, most attempts at molecular gastronomy such as at Chicago’s Alinea, are interesting, but gimmicky – not a restaurant I would like to go to very often. For the most part, Aviary avoids that cliché, and only dips into those areas when they contribute flavor or texture to a meal. Though the restaurant had a few problems with composition and consistency when they first opened, over my five visits, those issues seem to have been worked out. I have enjoyed every experience at the restaurant, and look forward to seeing how the menu changes with the seasons.

GRADES:

  • Atmosphere: C (loud when full)
  • Service: B+
  • Food: A-

Aviary

  • 1733 NE Alberta St. Portland, OR 97211; (503) 287-2400. AviaryPDX.com
  • ATMOSPHERE: Portland concrete modern.
  • SOUND LEVEL: Too loud on busy nights.
  • RECOMMENDED DISHES: Oxtail Croquettes, Seared Octopus Salad, Kusshi Oysters, Warm Snap Pea and Barley Salad, Crispy Pig Ear, Pana Cotta.
  • PRICE RANGE: “small plates” $8 to $11, “larger plates” $12to $16, desserts, $6.
  • HOURS: Dinner 5 to 10 p.m, until 11p.m Friday and Saturday.
  • RESERVATIONS: Open Table and via phone
  • CREDIT CARDS: All major cards.
  • WHEELCHAIR ACCESS: no steps to entrance; accessible restroom.

Aviary on Urbanspoon

Your thoughts are welcome

  1. Bryan says

    I’m glad to see a review of Aviary! We’ve gone a few times since it opened, and every time we’ve walked away very happy. Agreed the atmosphere is rather bland, but the food is great! The wait staff have always been a treat as well.

  2. Mike Thelin says

    Love to see love for this restaurant. Aviary is such a nice addition to the local scene. I really love this place.

  3. polarwanderer says

    Agreed, an exciting addition to Portland’s restaurant scene. My meals have been great and the service wonderful. They also have a nice wine list with interesting (primarily French) and well-priced options. The women that does their wines is very helpful. Just love this place.

  4. FoodGroupie says

    My wife and I had somewhat of a different experience. But that was when they just opened. Maybe we’ll have to go back and try it again.

  5. Jill-O says

    I was there in March and had a different experience. Not all bad, but very uneven. We found the salads, the tempura pumpkin, the crispy pig ear and steak tartare to be very good indeed, some of them great. But none of us at the table liked the slow poached egg dish, and we found the steak frites OK but not as good as many others in town. And there were a couple of other dishes that were OK, but that none of us would order again. Of the 3 desserts we had, one was very good (buttermilk panna cotta with passionfruit sorbet), one good (mascarpone blueberry tart), and one meh (coconut chocolate bread pudding – no discernible coconut flavor at all). We tried three different cocktails that night, and none of them were very good at all, I would not order a drink there again.

    I am hoping that the review above is a sign that things are improving there…because there was definitely enough to like and make one want to go back. …and because I want them to succeed! ;o)

    • Food Dude says

      Jill, you might give them another try. I have found the food is better now than it was in the first few months. I didn’t like the egg dish myself. They don’t have steak frites or the same bread pudding anymore.

      • reedsar says

        The review is most outdated. My experience with the service especially had much to be desired. We showed up 10 minutes before our res, and were told we were early and to wait in the bar. This would have been fine had there not been 6+ tables (including the one we were seated at 20 minutes later) unoccupied and set for seating. After sitting at the bar with 2 other people for 15 minutes, we got our drink order in. The drink was a delight, I must admit, so I thought it was a small hitch. We were seated, ordered the tiniest of appetizers, which reminded me and my companion of a scene from American Psycho because it was so small, and waited oh I don’t know, 30-45 minutes for our entrees to show up. Now they are not expensive, so I guess the small size is fine, as I’m not a big person, but after waiting over an hour for my food, I did feel disappointed. By the time our dessert menu made its way to us, my companion and I decided we’d starve to death before getting served, so we headed up to Salt and Straw for ice cream. The atmosphere was about as pretentious as most of the clientele. Funny, I live in the neighborhood but obviously was not in on the joke. There are so many great places in Portland, where the food and service are so great, that I am either surprised this place is still happening, or I just came in on an off night. Either way, I doubt I will be back anytime soon.

          • reedsar says

            The Oxtail Croquettes. They were delicious. But you know when you order a bottle of wine, and they pour you a sip to taste, and you say “yes it’s good,” then they pour you a full glass? Its kind of like that. Except without the getting more bit. It may have seemed smaller after waiting so long for our food. The reservation was 7:15, but since the bar was empty and there were many empty tables, I was surprised by the slowness. When a place is packed, I understand when I see people hustling around. It sadly wasn’t the case. We must have been seated at the table for invisible people. It was a bit disappointing, I’d really been looking forward to going there.

          • says

            Strange. The reason I asked, is a group of us were there last night too. We had the croquettes, and found them to be exactly the same as described in the review. As I said,

            It is always a surprise to order a $10 dish and get six Tater-Tot sized rolls on a plate, but I always waddle out the door for around $80 for two persons, including desserts. I wouldn’t want to spend that much every day, but I think the food here it is well worth it. As a friend of mine from Los Angeles said, “You wouldn’t believe what this meal would cost me at home!

            We had excellent service.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *