Review: Bistro Maison

Over the years, two things have remained constant in my emails. The first question is something to the effect of, “I’m coming to Portland in two weeks, where should I eat?” There is almost never anything about price, cuisine, etc. Ugh. The next most common question is, “Where should I eat when I’m in the wine country?” I’ve had the same question myself, and decided to find out. The Willamette Valley may not technically be part of Portland food and drink, but at one time or another, it is a destination for most of us.

I’ve been eating like a madman, at this point covering four different restaurants, and enjoying my time, driving in the back way through various small towns and acres of farmland. I’ll be posting a review every few months.

One generality: most of the restaurants are not up to the standard of high-end Portland establishments. A friend of mine says I don’t understand McMinnville, that they shouldn’t be compared to the Portland food scene. I disagree, and try to use the same standards everywhere I go; however, this doesn’t mean I don’t recommend these restaurants. Each has its own strengths and weaknesses, but I have enjoyed my meals at each one. For this reason, be sure to read all the way through every review for the summation.

Bistro Maison

Bistro Maison opened over seven years ago, and is now a McMinnville institution. It sits at the end on NE 3rd street in the picturesque old downtown area next to an even older train station. Parking is easy. The restaurant is casual and cozy. On a nice day, you’ll have a choice of dining inside or out, especially if you have planned ahead and made reservations, which are often necessary. I always opt for outside, as I don’t terribly mind it if an errant pine needle tumbles into my wine glass – consider it a benefit of dining al fresco.. The patio is terrific, a little enclave separated from the street, shaded by trees,  watched over by a dog named Lily, who sleeps quietly in the corner. Despite the plastic chairs, it is a comfortable way to indulge after an afternoon of wine country adventures. That’s not to slight the interior, which is also very pleasant. The inside is kind of like visiting your grandmother, with lighting and wallpaper which match the age of the building. French artwork dots the walls, and light jazz floats through the air. Padded leather chairs surround linen-covered tables. On a summer day, cross ventilation allows plenty of warm air to flow through. Service is generally top notch, with Chef Jean-Jacques and his wife Deborah both making sure everyone is comfortable. Veterans of the restaurant industry, between the two of them they have worked Paris, Rome, and NY City. Via email, I asked Deborah what brought them to McMinnville.

“My husband, Jean-Jacques, wanted to open his own restaurant in NYC.  Meaning no investors, no partners, no money people.  After 40 years in the kitchen, he was getting frustrated and tired of running with the bulls of Manhattan.  Happens to many chefs when they hit their late 40s…

He had this brilliant idea of having his wife, me, quit her job and work with him.  After thinking about his offer, I said I would, BUT… we have to own the property, building, and every piece of equipment in case we wanted to kill each other after the first year.

We searched many locations in the US.  Cities, the North Fork of Long Island & Northern California were out because too much $$$ for the real estate.  When we saw the Willamette Valley, it was a no brainer.   We were embracing the future food and wine destination in the US.  We felt so lucky to have found it this soon.”

They finally settled in MAC, and opened Bistro Maison, where they have one of the most passionate groups of followers I’ve ever seen.

The wine list is quite interesting, and bigger than the version posted on their website. All of the wines are personally picked by Deborah, and I think she does a good job of meeting a variety of price points and showcasing wines from Oregon and other regions. Many lists will have pages of redundancies (as in, fifteen Oregon Pinot Gris), but this one lumps similar ‘characters’ on the same line, creating more space while still offering multiple choices. For instance, when we were there for lunch I had three choices of Vouvray by the half bottle, and it was all contained in one line – as the creator of the list realized that they were of the same cloth. However, there were different vintages, styles and producers. If I have any complaint, it is that the markup is higher than I normally see.

The Bistro has a large amount of splits, or halt-bottles, which is great if you are worried about driving back to Portland, as well as a selection of by-the-glass pours. Wine service is excellent. When ordering by the glass, they bring out a couple of bottles and give a taste of each one so you can decide which one best fits your fancy.

Service is excellent, the timing on all of my meals has been just right, with the only unusual moment occurring when the server recites the entire specials menu to you. Strange because the same thing is written on the piece of paper in your hand. Charming, but strange.

Bistro Maison’s menu is mostly French, or French influenced, with the incongruous exception of house-made ravioli, which I didn’t try, but it had better be good for $25. They do best with items that showcase seasonal ingredients. Berries, peaches, corn, etc., have been wonderful this summer, and they use them to their best advantage, whether as a sly accompaniment to an entrée, or as the main event.

The three soups I’ve tried have been pretty good. Shrimp bisque was excellent, with a nice full body, and lots of flavor ($6). My last visit was on a warm summer night, and I tried both the gazpacho with basil puree, and another version with local corn and Vidalia onion. Both were fairly bursting of summer, and a thoroughly pleasant way to start the meal ($6).

Salads are large, and could easily serve two. One that interested me was almost a caprese with local peaches and mozzarella, and green and purple basil, drizzled with extra-virgin olive oil and balsamic reduction. One time, the peaches were so hard I couldn’t cut through them with a fork, and had to use my knife. Not so great. Another time they were soft, luscious, and full of flavor, but the fresh buffala mozzarella was a bit chewy and lacked much flavor. This dish was a good idea, but both times one component or the other left me unimpressed. A little seasoning would have done wonders ($13).

More successful was a salad with Neskowin pepper greens, bacon, local berries, toasted almonds & triple cream cow’s milk cheese, berry & nut vinaigrette. In August, the berries were absolutely fantastic, and all the flavors and textures went together beautifully ($10).

Mussels are always a good choice, and are available with different preparations, depending on the mood of the chef. Served with pomme frites (or French fries) they are fresh and flavorful ($18).

A Carlton Farms pork chop was a nice thick cut, but was suffering from “modern” pork syndrome, and had less fat than I prefer to give it flavor. It was properly cooked, and tender. Fresh grilled peaches on top gave a slightly sweet contrast; however, having it sitting in a peach sauce was a bit over the top for my tastes. Simple would have been better. The same chop with mixed berries was much better. The chop came with a side of average mashed potatoes, and wonderful green beans which tasted as if they were picked for our meal ($25).

One evening, my hanger steak, or onglet, was served with a shallot and wine reduction. Another night it was so tough, I gave up on a couple of slices where there was a bit of membrane left on. It would have helped had it been sliced properly. Yes, I got it medium rare. On a second night, it was just fine. The fries had a similar issue. One time just lousy – under-seasoned, yet another time they were terrific. Consistency seems to be a problem here, but even when they were prepared properly, my steaks were just average ($18).

Desserts are pleasant, and somewhat above average. I’ve tried profiteroles au chocolat, which were fine, served warm with warm chocolate sauce ($6). Moelleux au chocolat is a molten chocolate cake, which was just what you’d expect ($7). The best was a Napoleon, which was about four inches tall, made up of crispy flaky layers, with ice cream and fresh summer berries. This was an excellent dessert ($7). Whether you order dessert or not, they will bring out a large bowl of hazelnuts and nutcrackers, an easy way to end a meal.

Much of the food at Bistro Maison is average, but after an afternoon of wine tasting, it’s really a nice place to relax and wind down. Park at the opposite end of downtown and stroll down the street to the restaurant; it’s a nice, short walk. The Bistro staff is warm, the restaurant inviting. Service is way above average, with hardly a misstep in 3 visits. Relax, drink some wine, converse and stare up at the stars. If I was in the area looking for a meal, I wouldn’t hesitate to go back. Sometimes just average is fine, when the service and environment makes for an overall above average experience.

  • Phone: (503) 474-1888
  • Address: 729 NE Third St, McMinnville, OR 97128. Map
  • Hours: Dinner Wed-Thurs 6pm-9pm, Fri-Sat 5pm-9pm, Sun 3pm-8pm. Brunch & Lunch Wed-Fri 11:30am-2pm, Sun 12:00pm-3pm. Reservations requested via email or phone.
  • Website: BistroMaison.com

View Larger Map
Bistro Maison on Urbanspoon

Your thoughts are welcome

  1. hank says

    I’m really glad you are doing this because every time I head down there I am at a loss for where to eat, and it usually ends badly.

  2. bird says

    Jean-Jacque is an expert with the French Cheese Omelet. He is a master with fish and sauces. I love being at Bistro Maison, anytime. In summer, the garden seating is intimate and relaxing. I’m lunching there on Friday.

  3. mczlaw says

    With Nick’s, La Rambla and now Thistle within a few paces of Bistro Maison, there is really no reason to settle for “just average” food in McMinnville. This review seems a bit generous.

    –mcz

  4. katrus says

    A series on higher end restaurants outside of the Portland metro area would be great. I’ve always wondered about Tina’s in Dundee, and marveled at the lack of good places to eat in Bend. Maybe I just haven’t found the right ones yet. There’s a great place in Sisters, called Jen’s Garden, that deserves attention too.

  5. David says

    Food Dude, you are spot on! Bistro Maison lacks consistency and on any gievn visit it could be a great meal or it might be a dissapointing meal. One thing I really look for in a good restuarant is solid consistency and are more likely to return to a restuarant that constantly meets my expectations. I have had good experiences at Mistro but I’m not that excited about returning. I think it may be time to try the Joel Palmer restuarant in McMinville.

  6. says

    It has become our new tradition to take the kids there for Easter Brunch. Upstairs they have Easter-themed crafts and games for the kids. Downstairs the dining room is filled with couples and families enjoying brunch and champagne.

    Although I agree that the food can be inconsistent, the house made charcuterie plate and moules frites are always spot on.

    Tip… avoid things en croute — the dense puff pastry can detract from the dish.

  7. Robert says

    My wife and I moved to the Portland area last summer. We value a quiet, relaxed environment almost as much as the quality of the food. After several visits to some of Portland’s finest, we discovered the Bistro Maision on a trip back from the coast. The food and service was excellent and we really enjoyed the casual setting. You can add our name to the group of passionate followers, we look forward to many return visits.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *